Uncertain World: Russia and EU vie for title of most unpredictable

© RIA NovostiFyodor Lukyanov
Fyodor Lukyanov - Sputnik International
The latest Russia-EU summit in Brussels took place in unusual circumstances. President Dmitry Medvedev was in attendance as the outgoing head of state and the whole world was talking about how Russia has changed in the wake of the recent parliamentary elections...

The latest Russia-EU summit in Brussels took place in unusual circumstances. President Dmitry Medvedev was in attendance as the outgoing head of state and the whole world was talking about how Russia has changed in the wake of the recent parliamentary elections and how the usual political stability has given way to uncharted territory.


It is even harder to understand what is going on in Europe. It would have been considered alarmist to talk about the collapse of the euro and even the EU itself not long ago, whereas now even this could happen. In fact, it’s now used to scare European leaders into taking aggressive measures and adopting a more responsible attitude.

The EU summit in Brussels took place a week before the Russia-EU meeting. It was described as an historic victory. Although the United Kingdom opposed the Franco-German proposals on a budgetary and fiscal union, other EU members seemed to accept them. Measures to unify economic policy and impose strict budget and fiscal discipline are essential, but isn’t it too late to take them?

In effect, such measures amount to federalization and seriously limit sovereignty in favor of supra-national bodies. Perhaps such a project could have succeeded in the second half of the 1990s, when European integration and ambition were at their peak. Now the tune has changed. The project is expected to collapse, and tensions between the EU countries are mounting. Ordinary people in these countries do not understand what’s going on or what the proposed measures will do. Distrust of elites is rampant and leadership has been unconvincing.

Under such circumstances, the EU countries will have to take steps to boost accountability and deepen integration. Coordinating these measures is an agonizing process but they still will have to be ratified by all member states. Problems will arise practically everywhere and in countries where a referendum will be required the situation may be hopeless. Even the heads of state and government that supported the new document last week are not necessarily ready to live by such rigid rules. President Nicolas Sarkozy said a couple of days later that Paris is not prepared to forgo its sovereignty.

London’s refusal to join the next stage of integration (the Czech Republic, Hungary and Sweden also remain hesitant) marks the beginning of the EU’s inevitable stratification. The talk about multi-speed Europe has been going on for a long time but each time this idea was refuted as contradicting the union’s original commitment to equality. Now it will become reality by itself.

Russia is a major EU trade and economic partner and the EU is Russia’s biggest partner. Russia is now thinking about how it may be impacted by the integration crisis. Obviously, the sudden collapse of the entire structure, the euro and the EU itself in the worst case, would hurl the world into recession. This will affect everything, including hydrocarbon prices, which are critical for Russia.

If we assume that the worst-case scenario will be averted, and this is in the vital interests of major EU countries, Russia may stand to gain from the transformation of the EU. In any case, greater sovereignty will lead member states to independently build their relations with major states, such as Russia, once they are no longer able to rely on the EU as their foreign agent. The EU will not disappear as an instrument of pursuing coordinated interests. Gazprom, which recently has been an object of coordinated pressure under the pretext of anti-monopoly measures, has no cause to hope for a better position. When interests coincide, different countries will willingly utilize centralized institutions. However, there are spheres in which different countries have different ideas about their interests in Russia, which creates more freedom to maneuver.

Any economic problems that may arise in the EU as a result of the integration crisis will compel individual countries and the EU as a whole to take a greater interest in major or promising markets. Russia’s serious financial reserves may be very helpful for Europe. Strange as it may seem, the aggravation of the crisis in the EU may even help promote a long-standing priority of Russian diplomacy, visa-free travel, simply because the Europeans may wish to remove any extra barriers to expanding economic cooperation. The document on moving closer to visa-free travel is a positive development because it maps out some practical steps. However, subsequent steps are not even mentioned. Implementation of the terms does not automatically lift the requirement for short-term visas. The sides must make a political decision based on factors that have nothing to do with the heart of the matter.

The context of Russia-EU relations is changing. Before Russia was seen as the unpredictable party but now the Europeans are catching up in this respect. The intrigue continues to grow. 

The views expressed in this article are the author’s and may not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti.


Is Russia unpredictable? Perhaps, but one shouldn’t exaggerate – its randomness often follows a consistent pattern. But is the world at large predictable? The past two decades have seen all forecasts refuted more than once and have taught us only one thing – to be ready for any change. This column is on what the nations and governments are facing in the era of global uncertainty.

Fyodor Lukyanov is Editor-in-Chief of the Russia in Global Affairs journal – the most authoritative source of expertise on Russian foreign policy and global developments. He is also a frequent commentator on international affairs and contributes to various media in the United States, Europe and China, including academic journals Social Research, Europe-Asia Studies, Columbia Journal of International Affairs. Mr. Lukyanov is a senior member of the Council on Foreign and Defense Policy and a member of the Presidential Council on Human Rights and Civic Society Institutions. He holds a degree from Moscow State University.

Uncertain World: Destructive Soviet nostalgia

Uncertain World: The never-ending missile defense debate

Uncertain World: The Russian-Georgian war as a turning point

Uncertain World: Russia and Europe: Friends and interests

Uncertain World: Nord Stream and the future of Russian energy policy

Uncertain World: Russia’s WTO entry as the end of the post-Soviet era

Uncertain World: Post-Gaddafi Libya - more questions than answers

Uncertain World: Endgame in Ukraine

Uncertain World: Kiev plays without rules and risks it all

Uncertain World: The secure Eastern Partnership

Uncertain World: Vladimir Putin 3.0

Uncertain World: Post-Soviet inferiority complex

Uncertain World: The EU needs a political goal to survive

Uncertain World: The opportunity that wasn’t

Uncertain World: Why is China silent?

Uncertain World: Russia proposes a new Korean paradigm

Uncertain World: The balance that tripped up America

Uncertain World: Ukraine continues to chase two hares

Uncertain World: Russian lethargy three years after the Russia-Georgia war

Uncertain World: Oslo tragedy as an ill omen

Uncertain World: The reckless West

Uncertain World: Armenia and Azerbaijan’s shaky status quo

Uncertain World: Out of the confusion, conspiracy theories emerge

Uncertain World: Inertia and maneuvering in Russia’s foreign policy season

Uncertain World: Twenty years after the Balkan tragedy

Uncertain World: SCO’s 10 year search for balance

Uncertain World: Epilogue on joint missile defense

Uncertain World: Time for reflection

Uncertain World: Georgia’s risky decision to recognize the Circassian genocide

Uncertain World: Europe after Sofitel

Uncertain World: Pakistan’s vicious circle

Uncertain World: The master of historical byplay

Uncertain World: CSTO must evolve into military alliance

Uncertain World: Arab spring - after the euphoria has faded

Uncertain World: BRICS goes from fantasy to reality

Uncertain World: History and uncertain future spark heated debate

Uncertain World: Those peace-loving Germans

Uncertain World: Putin, Medvedev split over Libya

Uncertain World: In pursuit of common sense

Uncertain World: Vice President Biden’s reconnaissance visit to Moscow

Uncertain World: Yanukovych has boosted Ukraine’s stability – but for how long?

Uncertain World: Learning from Libya and Singapore

Uncertain World: Why don't Russia and Europe need politics to cooperate?

Uncertain World: Russian-Japanese territorial dispute flares up

Uncertain World: Europe without ambitions

Uncertain World: Terrorism’s local roots

Uncertain World: East-West democracy in Tunisia

Uncertain World: Master of intrigue

Uncertain World: Political responses to economic challenges in the next decade

Uncertain World: U.S.-Russian alliance cannot be ruled out

Uncertain World: A troubled year across the former Soviet Union

Uncertain World: Arguments against Russia joining NATO

Uncertain World: Lukashenko set for re-election, not surprisingly

Uncertain World: WikiLeaks document dump to undermine Obama’s clout in Moscow

Uncertain World: Unfinished business - Asia’s troubles rooted in a disputed past

Uncertain World: A quarter-century of going in circles

Uncertain World: The disputed Kuril Islands and Russia’s broader Asian strategy

Uncertain World: Talking Afghanistan without schadenfreude

Uncertain World: Russia’s Asia challenge

To participate in the discussion
log in or register
Заголовок открываемого материала