The prospect of America continuing its military involvement in the Middle East and putting more "boots on the ground" is a recipe for disaster, not a solution to a problem like Daesh (Islamic State/ISIL) according to Peter Van Buren, a US author and 24-year veteran of the US State Department.
"Time to remind him or her [US presidential candidates] that Washington's war on terror strategy has already sent at least $1.6 trillion down the drain, and left thousands of American troops and hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of Muslims dead. Along the way we lost precious freedoms to the ever-expanding national security state," Van Buren writes in a recent article for his WeMeantWell.com site.
The US-led coalition is determined to capture Mosul in Iraq and Raqqa in Syria, the US Defense Secretary stressed. During the event at Davos, Carter pointed out that Washington's allies in the region have not been doing enough to defeat Daesh and added that there will be "boots on the ground" in Iraq and Syria.
According to Van Buren, however, more air attack sorties and fighting are unlikely to halt the Daesh advance. Firstly, he said, Washington should cut off Daesh's sources of funding.
"As long as the US insists on flying air attack sorties (and your candidate may unfortunately need to do so to cover his/her right flank), direct them far more intensely than at present against one of ISIS's [Daesh's] main sources of cash: oil exports. Blow up trucks moving oil. Blow up wellheads in ISIS-dominated areas. Finding targets is not hard," the former US State Department official writes.
"The same should go for Turkey's behavior toward [Daesh]," he continues, referring to Ankara's "determination" to fight Kurdish forces (which are fighting the terrorist organization) and the way the Turkish leadership allows jihadists to enter Syria.
Van Buren also calls attention to Ankara's involvement in funneling arms to various Islamist groups in Syria, adding that it should be brought to an end.
At the same time, Washington should make it clear to Saudi Arabia and other Sunni Gulf leaders that they must stop funding Daesh.
"Forget a 'no-fly zone' over northern Syria — another fruitless 'solution' to the problem of the Islamic State [Daesh] that various presidential candidates are now plugging — and use the international banking system to create a no-flow zone," he stresses.
"Get out. Land the planes, ground the drones, and withdraw. Pull out the boots, the trainers, the American combatants and near combatants (whatever the euphemism of the moment for them may be)… Throwing more money (lives, global prestige…) into the pot won't alter the cards you're holding," Van Buren underscores.
Washington is unable to ultimately mend the situation in Syria and Iraq given the 14-year record of its failures in the Middle East, North Africa and Central Asia.
"It's time for the US to stand back and let local actors deal with the present situation. ISIS's [Daesh's] threat to us is actually minimal… Without Washington further roiling the situation, it's a movement whose limits will quickly enough become apparent," the retired American official states.