https://sputnikglobe.com/20230315/us-account-of-black-sea-incident-unrealistic-as-su-27-would-have-sustained-serious-damages---expert-1108438667.html
US Account of Black Sea Incident Unrealistic as Su-27 Would Have Sustained Serious Damages - Expert
US Account of Black Sea Incident Unrealistic as Su-27 Would Have Sustained Serious Damages - Expert
Sputnik International
The US account of events surrounding the fall of an American drone into the Black Sea after an encounter with a Russian fighter jet is unrealistic, as the Su-27 would have suffered considerable damage if it had hit the MQ-9 Reaper drone, French military expert Xavier Moreau told Sputnik.
2023-03-15T23:54+0000
2023-03-15T23:54+0000
2023-03-15T23:53+0000
world
black sea
mq-9 reaper
su-27
military expert
xavier moreau
us
russia
https://cdn1.img.sputnikglobe.com/img/07e4/08/09/1080113262_0:123:3207:1926_1920x0_80_0_0_1d3f987d6ee407d7684c5796ace31826.jpg
"The Russian SU-27 fighter could not have hit the American MQ-9 drone," Moreau said. "The Reaper drone has a significant mass: about 4.5 tons. Its force of inertia is enormous and makes it very difficult to overturn it.""The nose of a hunter-fighter plane is stuffed with fragile electronics, such as radar, pitot tubes, etc. under a hood in composite materials or polyester. It cannot be used to ram into an aircraft. The US version is simply impossible."The expert believes that the drone could have crashed as a result of the use of electronic warfare by the Russian military, or its genuine malfunction. He also finds it strange that the US military has published neither drone footage nor satellite photos, whereas the Russian military published video footage of the encounter showing that the US drone was equipped with the Gorgon Stare advanced surveillance system, which is possibly the true cause of the US's "overreaction." "The US refused to deliver it [Gorgon Stare] to Ukraine, for fear of seeing it falling in the hands of the Russian army. Russia has retrieved parts of the downed drone, it seems, and could study its new system. That is maybe what explains the American overreaction," Moreau said. Moreau also believes that this incident will not lead to an escalation between the countries, even though Washington has repeatedly used such cases to start conflicts. He cited the 1964 Gulf of Tonkin incident, which led to the rapid escalation of US military involvement in the Vietnam War, and the bogus discovery of weapons of mass destruction in Saddam Hussein's Iraq, which Washington used as a pretext to start its invasion. "The American MQ-9 Reaper destruction will probably be limited to a diplomatic incident with strong statements from both sides and no military retaliation on the part of the US. No one has any interest in an extreme rise in tensions," Moreau concluded.
https://sputnikglobe.com/20230315/what-message-does-black-sea-reaper-crash-send-about-us-spying-missions-and-double-standards-1108426861.html
black sea
russia
Sputnik International
feedback@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rossiya Segodnya“
2023
Sputnik International
feedback@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rossiya Segodnya“
News
en_EN
Sputnik International
feedback@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rossiya Segodnya“
Sputnik International
feedback@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rossiya Segodnya“
black sea incident, reaper drone, su-27, damages, expert, xavier moreau
black sea incident, reaper drone, su-27, damages, expert, xavier moreau
US Account of Black Sea Incident Unrealistic as Su-27 Would Have Sustained Serious Damages - Expert
MOSCOW (Sputnik) - The US account of events surrounding the fall of an American drone into the Black Sea after an encounter with a Russian fighter jet is unrealistic, as the Su-27 would have suffered considerable damage if it had hit the MQ-9 Reaper drone, French military expert Xavier Moreau told Sputnik.
"The Russian SU-27 fighter could not have hit the American MQ-9 drone," Moreau said. "The Reaper drone has a significant mass: about 4.5 tons. Its force of inertia is enormous and makes it very difficult to overturn it."
"It is a safe bet that the Russian fighter that would have tried to physically destabilize the Reaper with its aircraft body or wings, would have put itself in absolute danger. The wings also contain fuel. And taking the drone from behind – as the US suggests – is almost impossible," the expert underscored.
"The nose of a hunter-fighter plane is stuffed with fragile electronics, such as radar, pitot tubes, etc. under a hood in composite materials or polyester. It cannot be used to ram into an aircraft. The US version is simply impossible."
The expert believes that the drone could have crashed as a result of the use of electronic warfare by the Russian military, or its genuine malfunction.
He also finds it strange that the US military has published neither drone footage nor satellite photos, whereas the Russian military published video footage of the encounter showing that the US drone was equipped with the Gorgon Stare advanced surveillance system, which is possibly the true cause of the US's "overreaction."
"The US refused to deliver it [Gorgon Stare] to Ukraine, for fear of seeing it falling in the hands of the Russian army. Russia has retrieved parts of the downed drone, it seems, and could study its new system. That is maybe what explains the American overreaction," Moreau said.
Moreau also believes that this incident will not lead to an escalation between the countries, even though Washington has repeatedly used such cases to start conflicts. He cited the 1964 Gulf of Tonkin incident, which led to the rapid escalation of US military involvement in the Vietnam War, and the bogus discovery of weapons of mass destruction in Saddam Hussein's Iraq, which Washington used as a pretext to start its invasion.
"The American MQ-9 Reaper destruction will probably be limited to a diplomatic incident with strong statements from both sides and no military retaliation on the part of the US. No one has any interest in an extreme rise in tensions," Moreau concluded.
The Russian Defense Ministry explained earlier Tuesday that a Su-27 fighter had been scrambled to follow an unidentified MQ-9 Reaper drone, which was moving toward the Russian border and ended up falling in the Black Sea as a result of sharp maneuvering. The ministry stressed the Russian jet neither communicated with the drone nor used force against it.
The US European Command, on the other hand, claimed the Russian jet had struck the drone's propeller during an "unsafe and unprofessional intercept," which resulted in its fall. The US is now trying to retrieve the drone's debris.
