- Sputnik International
World
Get the latest news from around the world, live coverage, off-beat stories, features and analysis.

US Defence Department Wasted $231mln on White Elephant Missile Program

© Photo : mda.milPrecision Tracking Space System
Precision Tracking Space System - Sputnik International
Subscribe
The Precision Tracking Space System was touted as a necessary defence against nuclear attack from another state, but it should never have left the drawing board, experts told The Los Angeles Times last week.

This picture taken on March 21, 2015 shows US troops from the 5th Battalion of the 7th Air Defense Regiment emplace a launching station of the Patriot air and missile defence system at a test range in Sochaczew, Poland - Sputnik International
US 2020 Missile Defense Plan for Europe Has 'Strategic Consequences'
The Precision Tracking Space System (PTSS), which cost $231 million to develop before it was scrapped two years ago, had deficiencies that were so obvious they could have been identified by a simple sketch, experts have told a Los Angeles Times investigation.

“It’s an example of what can go wrong in defence procurement: Huge amounts of money just pissed away on things that should never have advanced beyond a study,” David K. Barton, a physicist and radar engineer who served on a National Academy of Sciences review panel of US missile-defence programs, told the newspaper.

PTSS was proposed by the US Department of Defence’s Missile Defence Agency in 2009 as a way of enabling the complete trajectory of an enemy missile to be followed, even when it had left the Earth’s atmosphere. 

The ambitious, but unnecessary, system was supposed to use a constellation of infrared sensors in space to track a missile in the cold environment of space, and allow the US to follow a warhead all the way from “birth to death.”

© Sputnik / David B. GleasonThe US Department of Defense
The US Department of Defense - Sputnik International
The US Department of Defense
Other missile defence systems rely on information from military satellites and radars, which are able to detect the heat produced after a warhead is launched but cannot detect the heat signature in space.

The project was justified by its supporters as a necessary defence against what US hawks termed “rogue states” such as North Korea and Iran, but was officially discontinued in 2013.

The LA Times reported a host of reasons why the aborted program should have never left the drawing board. Among its outstanding findings, the investigation found that the system would have required twice as many satellites for the full coverage of the Northern Hemisphere, and that the satellites “would have been blind to warheads flying over the Arctic — one of the likely paths for missiles launched from Iran or North Korea.”

India Test-Fires Long-Range Missile System Developed With Israel - Sputnik International
India Test-Fires Long-Range Missile System Developed With Israel
In addition, the system’s nine to 12 sensors would not have been powerful enough to distinguish warheads from debris, and existing satellites and radars are able to do much of what it was billed as being able to do.

“The Missile Defense Agency’s cost estimate — $10 billion over 20 years — was way off. PTSS would have cost at least $24 billion over that time period, according to an independent assessment done for the Pentagon and Congress.”

“You could have done it on a napkin,” said Philip E. Coyle III, former director of operational testing and evaluation for the Pentagon, about the lack of vetting for the doomed project. 

“All you had to do was put pencil to paper.”

Newsfeed
0
To participate in the discussion
log in or register
loader
Chats
Заголовок открываемого материала