Analysts: Failure to Renew 2010 START Treaty Could Trigger Global Nuke Arms Race

© AFP 2023 / Paul CROCKUS Air Force B-52 bomber, file photo.
US Air Force B-52 bomber, file photo. - Sputnik International
WASHINGTON (Sputnik) - The failure of the Trump administration to renew the 2010 Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New START) may trigger a new arms race for the United States with both Russia and China, analysts told Sputnik.

Monday marked the ninth anniversary of the signing of New START by Russian President Dmitri Medvedev and US President Barack Obama. The 2010 New START Treaty is scheduled to expire on February 5, 2021 with an option to renew it until 2026.

No Nuclear Restrictions

There are no indications, according to experts, that Trump or his National Security Adviser John Bolton wants to renew the treaty when it runs out in 2021.

Tokyo Institute of Technology Visiting Professor Subrata Ghoshroy told Sputnik that based on budget projections, the future looks grim.

"Given the large budget projections for the US nuclear weapons program in the next 30 years, we could see the reappearance of a dangerous arms race with Russia and China", Ghoshroy said on Monday.

READ MORE: NATO Discusses Measures if Russia Violates INF Treaty — Stoltenberg

If START is not renewed, for the first time in more than 50 years the world will be without any restrictions whatsoever on thousands of nuclear weapons that exist today, Ghoshroy, Research Affiliate in Science and Technology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology stressed.

In this undated photo released Saturday, Aug. 6, 2016, by China's Xinhua News Agency, a pair of Chinese fighter jets fly during a patrol over the South China Sea - Sputnik International
US' INF-Banned Missiles to Heat Up Tensions in Europe, South China Sea – Analyst
"The consequences of not extending the START treaty would mean we would be entering a period of grave uncertainty in nuclear stability", Ghoshroy cautioned.

Trump still had the opportunity to seek to save START and being cleared on the charge of colluding with Russia in the 2016 presidential election campaign gave him renewed freedom to do so, Ghoshroy noted.

"I think that the START renewal decision is a tossup. If… Bolton has his way, it is quite possible that the treaty will not be renewed. However, with his apparent victory in the Russiagate investigation, [Trump] might once again feel that he has some space to mend relations with Russia", he said.

Nevertheless, even if the treaty was to be renewed, it remained "highly unlikely that the newly developed systems would be included", Ghoshroy advised.

READ MORE: US Gen. Sheds Light on Plans to Deploy Cruise Missiles in Europe Amid INF Exit

Trump’s decision to pull out of the 1987 Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty had further generated a political and diplomatic climate hostile to renewing START, Ghoshroy remarked.

"Trump is commanding the Titanic as far as arms control is concerned", he said. The collapse of the INF Treaty "has clearly contributed to a deficiency in trust between the two nations, which is essential to arms control", he said.

Dim Prospects

Russia and the United States have long accused each other of violating the INF treaty, and both sides have denied the accusations. On 1 February, the United States announced it was suspending its obligations under the 1987 INF Treaty and launched the withdrawal process. Washington said the withdrawal process will be completed within six months unless Russia remedies its alleged treaty violations. Russia responded in kind by withdrawing from its obligations.

READ MORE: US Manipulated Figures to Seem to Comply With New START Treaty — Moscow

US political commentator and historian Dan Lazare agreed that prospects for START renewal looked dim especially in light of his role undermining the INF treaty.

"Things do not look good for an extension of New START", Lazare told Sputnik.

Bolton’s continued role as Trump’s third National Security Adviser tilted the odds heavily against START renewal, Lazare explained.

"John Bolton, the man who helped derail the ABM [Anti-Ballistic Missile] Treaty back in 2002 and personally demolished the INF Treaty earlier this year, is a hawk's hawk who has never seen an arms-control treaty he likes. So if he's still in power a year from now, the chances of an extension seem slim", he said.

US President Donald Trump before the start of the G20 summit in Buenos Aires (File photo). - Sputnik International
Trump Administration Interested in Extending New START Treaty - Undersecretary
But even before Bolton took over as National Security Adviser last year and well before Trump won the presidency in November 2016, US-Russian relations had been on a prolonged downward spiral, Lazare recalled.

"This will be extremely dangerous. But what's important to keep in mind that non-extension would be as much a consequence as a cause. US-Russian relations have been deteriorating for years, particularly since Euromaidan in early 2014", he said.

After being elected president, Trump had been caught in the hostile atmosphere and negative dynamics of superpower relations, Lazare noted.

"Although Trump campaigned on the need for a rapprochement with Moscow, Russiagate has forced him to reverse course and adopt positions that were even more bellicose than those of Obama", he said.

The rise of China and new weapon technologies such as hypersonic missiles and long-range nuclear-powered, nuclear-armed torpedoes had added new difficulties to the challenge of saving and expanding START to meet the security and technological challenges of a new era, Lazare emphasized.

"All are outside New START's purview and hence serve to undermine its effectiveness. As a result, the treaty may very well totter on its own in the face of an increasingly hostile international climate", he said.

READ MORE: US May Be Dragging Out Time Until New START Treaty Expires — Moscow

However, failure to renew the strategic treaty would ramp up hostilities even more, Lazare predicted.

Russian Defense Ministry officers seen here at the National Defense Management Center, Moscow - Sputnik International
Russian MoD Ready to Discuss START Treaty, Intensify Contacts
Such a failure would open the door to a new multi-dimensional nuclear arms race involving not only Russia and the United States, but China, North Korea, and Iran, Lazare said.

Under such circumstances, international military stability would decline at a time when political stability was on the downswing as well, Lazare stressed.

"It would not be a good combination. But it seems to be where the international system is heading even without people like Bolton to hurry the process along", he concluded.

Views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect those of Sputnik.

To participate in the discussion
log in or register
Заголовок открываемого материала