https://sputnikglobe.com/20231208/russia-to-target-frankensam-production-in-ukraine-as-soon-as-its-up-and-running-1115485502.html
Russia to Target FrankenSAM Production in Ukraine as Soon as It's Up and Running
Russia to Target FrankenSAM Production in Ukraine as Soon as It's Up and Running
Sputnik International
Washington has announced the transfer of technical documentation for the localization of production of arms from the FrankenSAM program – the air defense ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ created by combining Western missiles with Ukraine’s Soviet-era launchers and radars. Veteran military expert Andrei Koshkin explains why the program is destined to fail.
2023-12-08T19:21+0000
2023-12-08T19:21+0000
2023-12-08T19:39+0000
military
andrei koshkin
joe biden
military & intelligence
ukraine
kiev
russia
pentagon
nato
white house
https://cdn1.img.sputnikglobe.com/img/07e7/09/15/1113570609_0:83:1024:659_1920x0_80_0_0_c39997f72828a0f51d5a6b99c3798ae6.jpg
The White House released a press ‘fact sheet’ Wednesday indicating that “the Department of Defense and industry partners” had “provided Ukraine with technical data to start local production of some of the FrankenSAM projects that seek to enable Ukraine’s legacy air defense systems by integrating certain Western munitions.”“Parallel production of these systems in Ukraine and the United States will allow for faster fielding and enable Ukraine to contribute significantly to the sustainment of its air defense system,” the statement said.The FrankenSAM program, revealed to media in October, is designed to kill two birds with one stone, compensating for losses taken by Ukraine’s NATO-sourced air defense systems to Russian missile and drone strikes, and presenting the Pentagon with a chance for some penny-pinching as resources allocated to Kiev run dry amid wrangling in Washington over US President Joe Biden’s request for over $60 billion in additional aid.When fused with Ukraine’s stocks of old Soviet-era launchers and radars, FrankenSAMs promise to provide Kiev with a vintage air defense army, but will have difficulty fighting off modern Russian strike systems.But in a situation where additional US funds for Ukraine remain stalled in Congress, and where NATO is forced to organize a global scavenger hunt to slap together new weapons and ammo assistance packages for Kiev, the FrankenSAM project makes sense, retired Russian colonel and veteran military expert Andrei Koshkin told Sputnik.The systems’ effectiveness is another story, the observer said, noting that like the Abrams tanks that the US so “proudly delivered” earlier this fall, FrankenSAMs will face the same fate-speedy destruction, if and when they’re deployed on the frontlines. “They will not result in any shift in the balance of forces on the front in the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ favor,” Koshkin stressed.The Ukrainian battlespace is already familiar with the use of Frankenstein weaponry, the observer pointed out, with anti-Kiev militias in the Donbass resorting to salvaging whatever weapons they could to stave off the Ukrainian advance in 2014. The fact that it is now Kiev’s turn to do so “characterizes the very difficult situation in the Armed Forces of Ukraine, and isn't some kind of ascent or opportunity to strengthen Ukraine’s combat readiness,” as presented by Ukrainian officials and the Pentagon, Koshkin emphasized.Kiev is in no condition to build a large number of FrankenSAMs anyway, the military observer suggested, in part because its economic capacity to do so has been destroyed. Secondly, the FrankenSAMs’ garage-built nature carries with it all the problems typically associated with handmade equipment, including questionable functionality.“They have already collected and shipped out everything they had,” the observer said, pointing to Ukraine’s use of everything from M2 machine guns to 19th century Maxim machine guns. “They’re good, reliable machine guns. But the technology is from over a century ago, and so is the ammunition.” Ukraine has been turned into a “military laboratory for the disposal of everything the West doesn’t need,” and the FrankenSAM program will suffer the same fate, the Koshkin believes.Ultimately, Koshkin is confident that Russia’s military will be on the lookout of any efforts by the US to establish “joint production” on Ukrainian territory, and that it will level these capabilities in precision strikes if and when they're up and running.
https://sputnikglobe.com/20231021/pentagons-crafty-plan-ukraine-to-receive-frankenstein-air-defenses-from-us-1114355508.html
https://sputnikglobe.com/20231208/bidens-bid-to-bully-russia-into-peace-talks-on-ukraines-terms-reeks-of-desperation-1115483611.html
ukraine
kiev
russia
Sputnik International
feedback@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rosiya Segodnya“
2023
News
en_EN
Sputnik International
feedback@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rosiya Segodnya“
Sputnik International
feedback@sputniknews.com
+74956456601
MIA „Rosiya Segodnya“
united states, ukraine, russia, what is frankensam, sam, surface to air missile, hybrid missile defenses
united states, ukraine, russia, what is frankensam, sam, surface to air missile, hybrid missile defenses
Russia to Target FrankenSAM Production in Ukraine as Soon as It's Up and Running
19:21 GMT 08.12.2023 (Updated: 19:39 GMT 08.12.2023) Washington has announced the transfer of technical documentation for the localization of production of arms from the FrankenSAM program – the air defense ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ created by combining Western missiles with Ukraine’s Soviet-era launchers and radars. Veteran military expert Andrei Koshkin explains why the program is destined to fail.
The White House released a press ‘fact sheet’ Wednesday indicating that “the Department of Defense and industry partners” had “provided Ukraine with technical data to start local production of some of the FrankenSAM projects that seek to enable Ukraine’s legacy air defense systems by integrating certain Western munitions.”
“Parallel production of these systems in Ukraine and the United States will allow for faster fielding and enable Ukraine to contribute significantly to the sustainment of its air defense system,” the statement said.
“These initial deliverables,” combined with other US assistance, “will not only expand US-Ukraine cooperation and provide Ukraine with the capabilities it needs to be successful on the battlefield in the short term, but will support Ukraine’s long-term economic recovery and defense,” the White House assured.
The FrankenSAM program,
revealed to media in October, is designed to kill two birds with one stone, compensating for losses taken by Ukraine’s NATO-sourced air defense systems to Russian missile and drone strikes, and presenting the Pentagon with a chance for some penny-pinching as resources allocated to Kiev run dry amid wrangling in Washington over US President Joe Biden’s request for over
$60 billion in additional aid.
21 October 2023, 10:08 GMT
FrankenSAM consists of at least three projects – one involving the creation of a ground-based, short-range air defense system using AIM-9M Sidewinder missiles, a second involving fitting AIM-7 Sparrow missiles to early version of the Buk missile system, and a third involving the modernization of the HAWK medium-range SAM system.
All three American weapons systems are old, going back to the 1950s.
When fused with Ukraine’s stocks of old Soviet-era launchers and radars, FrankenSAMs promise to provide Kiev with a vintage air defense army, but will have difficulty fighting off modern Russian strike systems.
But in a situation where additional US funds for Ukraine remain stalled in Congress, and where NATO is forced to organize a global scavenger hunt to slap together new weapons and ammo assistance packages for Kiev, the FrankenSAM project makes sense, retired Russian colonel and veteran military expert Andrei Koshkin told Sputnik.
“When it comes to the relevance of creating some kind of monster, some kind of Frankenstein containing elements from Western weapons systems and Soviet weapons systems allowing for the use of available ammunition, this is very relevant today, given a situation in which the ‘dollar shower’ falling on Ukraine has dried up,” Koshkin said.
The systems’ effectiveness is another story, the observer said, noting that like the Abrams tanks that the US so “proudly delivered” earlier this fall, FrankenSAMs will face the same fate-speedy destruction, if and when they’re deployed on the frontlines. “They will not result in any shift in the balance of forces on the front in the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ favor,” Koshkin stressed.
The Ukrainian battlespace is already familiar with the use of Frankenstein weaponry, the observer pointed out, with anti-Kiev militias in the Donbass resorting to salvaging whatever weapons they could to stave off the Ukrainian advance in 2014. The fact that it is now Kiev’s turn to do so “characterizes the very difficult situation in the Armed Forces of Ukraine, and isn't some kind of ascent or opportunity to strengthen Ukraine’s combat readiness,” as presented by Ukrainian officials and the Pentagon, Koshkin emphasized.
“I would rather characterize it as a sign of the wretchedness of the collective West,” Koshkin said, stressing it shows to the “whole world” that the US and its allies are not capable of meeting Ukraine’s military needs, notwithstanding boasting from Washington about its ability to force Russia to the negotiating table 'on Ukraine's terms.'
8 December 2023, 17:50 GMT
Kiev is in no condition to build a large number of FrankenSAMs anyway, the military observer suggested, in part because its economic capacity to do so has been destroyed. Secondly, the FrankenSAMs’ garage-built nature carries with it all the problems typically associated with handmade equipment, including questionable functionality.
“Where are the numbers? Where are the numbers showing that this program is viable, that it is sustainable in the current situation? There are no numbers, only empty statements,” Koshkin said, referring to the comments coming out of Washington on the FrankenSAM program. “There is no evidence that this program can change anything on the frontlines,” the observer reiterated.
“They have already collected and shipped out everything they had,” the observer said, pointing to Ukraine’s use of everything from M2 machine guns to 19th century Maxim machine guns. “They’re good, reliable machine guns. But the technology is from over a century ago, and so is the ammunition.” Ukraine has been turned into a “military laboratory for the disposal of everything the West doesn’t need,” and the FrankenSAM program will suffer the same fate, the Koshkin believes.
Ultimately, Koshkin is confident that Russia’s military will be on the lookout of any efforts by the US to establish “joint production” on Ukrainian territory, and that it will level these capabilities in precision strikes if and when they're up and running.
